Living with relatives offsets the harm caused by pathogens in natural populations

Living with relatives can be highly beneficial, enhancing reproduction and survival. However, high relatedness can increase susceptibility to pathogens, a phenomenon known as the ‘monoculture effect’. Here we examine if the benefits of living with relatives offsets the harm caused by pathogens, and if this depends if species typically live with kin. Using comparative meta-analysis across plants, animals and bacteria (nspecies= 56), we show that high within-group relatedness increases mortality when pathogens are present. Contrastingly, mortality decreased with relatedness when pathogens were rare, particularly in species that live with kin. Variation in pathogen abundances was lower across groups of relatives, but rates of mortality were more unpredictable. The effects of within-group relatedness were only evident when pathogens were manipulated, suggesting that the harm caused by pathogens is masked by the benefits of living with relatives. These results highlight the importance of kin selection for understanding disease spread in natural populations.