Emergent coexistence in multispecies microbial communities

Microbial communities are highly diverse, and understanding the factors that promote and modulate this diversity is a major area of research in microbial ecology. Recent work has proposed a reductionist perspective to microbial coexistence, where pairwise coexistence between strains in isolation is required for their coexistence in a more complex community. In this view, species exclusion in pairwise co-culture would preclude their coexistence in a more complex community too. An alternative view is that coexistence is a more complex property of the entire community, requiring the presence of additional community members. If this view were correct, competitive exclusion in pairwise co-culture would not necessarily preclude species coexistence in more complex community contexts. Empirically testing these alternative hypotheses is complicated by the intractably high microbial diversity of most natural communities, and the challenges of reconstituting every pair of coexisting species under the exact same habitat where their community of origin was assembled. To address this challenge, we have experimentally reconstituted all possible pairwise co-cultures between stably coexisting species from 13 different, low-diversity microbial enrichment communities, which had previously been assembled in a well-controlled synthetic habitat. We find that, when isolated from the rest of their community members, most species pairs fail to coexist. This result highlights the importance of community context for microbial coexistence and indicates that pairwise exclusion may not reflect the ability of species to coexist in more complex, multispecies ecosystems.