Structural variation discovery in wheat using PacBio high-fidelity sequencing

  1. Zhiliang Zhang
  2. Jijin Zhang
  3. Lipeng Kang
  4. Xuebing Qiu
  5. Song Xu
  6. Jun Xu
  7. Yafei Guo
  8. Zelin Niu
  9. Beirui Niu
  10. Aoyue Bi
  11. Xuebo Zhao
  12. Daxing Xu
  13. Jing Wang
  14. Changbin Yin
  15. Fei Lu
1 evaluations Published on
Read the full article Related papers
This article on Sciety

Abstract

Background

Structural variations (SVs) pervade plant genomes and contribute substantially to the phenotypic diversity. However, most SVs were ineffectively assayed because of their complex nature and the limitations of early genomic technologies. The recent advance in third-generation sequencing, particularly the PacBio high-fidelity (HiFi) sequencing technology, produces highly accurate long-reads and offers an unprecedented opportunity to characterize SVs’ structure and functionality. As HiFi sequencing is relatively new to population genomics, it is imperative to evaluate and optimize HiFi sequencing based SV detection before applying the technology at scale.

Results

We sequenced wheat genomes using HiFi reads, followed by a comprehensive evaluation of mainstream long-read aligners and SV callers in SV detection. The results showed that the accuracy of deletion discovery is markedly influenced by callers, which account for 87.73% of the variance, while both aligners (38.25%) and callers (49.32%) contributed substantially to the accuracy variance for insertions. Among the aligners, Winnowmap2 and NGMLR excelled in detecting deletions and insertions, respectively. For SV callers, SVIM achieved the best performance. We demonstrated that combining the aligners and callers mentioned above is optimal for SV detection. Furthermore, we evaluated the effect of sequencing depth on the accuracy of SV detection, showing that low-coverage HiFi sequencing is sufficiently robust for high-quality SV discovery.

Conclusions

This study thoroughly evaluated SV discovery approaches using HiFi reads, establishing optimal workflows to investigate structural variations in the wheat genome. The notable accuracy of SV discovery from low-coverage HiFi sequencing indicates that skim HiFi sequencing is effective and preferable to characterize SVs at the population level. This study will help advance SV discovery and decipher the biological functions of SVs in wheat and many other plants.

Related articles

Related articles are currently not available for this article.