Optimization of crossing strategy based on the usefulness criterion in inter-population crosses considering different genetic effects among populations

In the breeding programs of self-pollinated plants, achieving genetic improvement in multiple traits can be challenging when relying solely on a single biparental population. Interpopulation crosses are employed to integrate favorable alleles from multiple biparental populations to overcome this limitation. In this context, it is crucial to consider the distinct genetic effects in different populations. In this study, we utilized a selection method based on the usefulness criterion (UC) to identify cross pairs suitable for interpopulation crosses. We expanded this approach to enhance breeding programs accounting for varying genetic backgrounds within the genomic selection framework. Using the medicinal plant red perilla as the study material, we conducted simulations to compare the efficacy of selection based on estimated genomic breeding values with that based on UC. Our findings demonstrate that the proposed method is effective in facilitating the simultaneous improvement of multiple traits, particularly by considerably increasing genetic gains among the top-performing individuals in the population. Furthermore, we provide guidelines for implementing interpopulation crosses, including recommendations for the optimal generation for crossing and the appropriate reference generation for calculating the UC. The results obtained in this study offer valuable insights for small-scale breeding programs aimed at simultaneously enhancing multiple traits through inter-population crosses and are applicable to a wide range of crops, including neglected and underutilized species.